Deploy Schema Registry in Production on Confluent Platform

This topic describes the key considerations before going to production with your cluster. However, it is not an exhaustive guide to running your Schema Registry in production.

Hardware

If you’ve been following the normal development path, you’ve probably been playing with Schema Registry on your laptop or on a small cluster of machines laying around. But when it comes time to deploying Schema Registry to production, there are a few recommendations that you should consider. Nothing is a hard-and-fast rule.

Memory

Schema Registry uses Kafka as a commit log to store all registered schemas durably, and maintains a few in-memory indices to make schema lookups faster. A conservative upper bound on the number of unique schemas registered in a large data-oriented company like LinkedIn is around 10,000. Assuming roughly 1000 bytes heap overhead per schema on average, heap size of 1GB would be more than sufficient.

CPUs

CPU usage in Schema Registry is light. The most computationally intensive task is checking compatibility of two schemas, an infrequent operation which occurs primarily when new schemas versions are registered under a subject.

If you need to choose between faster CPUs or more cores, choose more cores. The extra concurrency that multiple cores offers will far outweigh a slightly faster clock speed.

Disks

Schema Registry does not have any disk resident data. It currently uses Kafka as a commit log to store all schemas durably and holds in-memory indices of all schemas. Therefore, the only disk usage comes from storing the log4j logs.

Network

A fast and reliable network is obviously important to performance in a distributed system. Low latency helps ensure that nodes can communicate easily, while high bandwidth helps shard movement and recovery. Modern data-center networking (1 GbE, 10 GbE) is sufficient for the vast majority of clusters.

Avoid clusters that span multiple data centers, even if the data centers are colocated in close proximity. Definitely avoid clusters that span large geographic distances.

Larger latencies tend to exacerbate problems in distributed systems and make debugging and resolution more difficult.

Often, people might assume the pipe between multiple data centers is robust or low latency. But this is usually not true and network failures might happen at some point. See the recommended Multi-Datacenter Setup.

JVM

We recommend running the latest version of JDK 1.8 with the G1 collector (older freely available versions have disclosed security vulnerabilities).

If you are still on JDK 1.7 (which is also supported) and you are planning to use G1 (the current default), make sure you’re on u51. We tried out u21 in testing, but we had a number of problems with the GC implementation in that version.

Our recommended GC tuning looks like this:

-Xms1g -Xmx1g -XX:MetaspaceSize=96m -XX:+UseG1GC -XX:MaxGCPauseMillis=20 \
       -XX:InitiatingHeapOccupancyPercent=35 -XX:G1HeapRegionSize=16M \
       -XX:MinMetaspaceFreeRatio=50 -XX:MaxMetaspaceFreeRatio=80

Important Configuration Options

The following configurations should be changed for production environments. These options depend on your cluster layout.

For multi-cluster deployments, configure Schema Registry to use Kafka-based primary election as described below. (See Schema Registry Configuration Reference for Confluent Platform for full descriptions of these properties.)

Kafka based primary election

Kafka based primary election is available in Confluent Platform 4.0 and later. This is the recommended method for leader election. To configure Schema Registry to use Kafka for primary election, configure the kafkastore.bootstrap.servers setting.

kafkastore.bootstrap.servers

The Kafka cluster containing the bootstrap servers specified in kafkastore.bootstrap.servers is used to coordinate Schema Registry instances (leader election), and store schema data. When Kafka security is enabled, kafkastore.bootstrap.servers is also used to specify security protocols that Schema Registry uses to connect to Kafka.

  • Type: list
  • Default: []
  • Importance: medium

listeners

Schema Registry identities are stored in ZooKeeper and are made up of a hostname and port. If multiple listeners are configured, the first listener’s port is used for its identity.

  • Type: list
  • Default: “http://0.0.0.0:8081”
  • Importance: high

host.name

even if inter.instance.listener.name is specified, or does not match any listener. (The schema, port and TLS configurations will continue to be picked based on the inter.instance.listener.name config, if it is set.)

  • Type: string
  • Default: “192.168.50.1”
  • Importance: high

Important

If host.name is set in a multi Schema Registry node environment, it must resolve to a valid location or URL from the other Schema Registry instance(s) to ensure communication between the nodes.

Note

Configure min.insync.replicas on the Kafka server for the internal _schemas topic that stores all registered schemas to be higher than 1. For example, if the kafkastore.topic.replication.factor is 3, then set min.insync.replicas on the Kafka server for the kafkastore.topic to 2. This ensures that the register schema write is considered durable if it gets committed on at least 2 replicas out of 3. Furthermore, it is best to set unclean.leader.election.enable to false so that a replica outside of the isr is never elected leader (potentially resulting in data loss).

The full set of configuration options are documented in Schema Registry Configuration Reference for Confluent Platform.

ZooKeeper based primary election

Important

ZooKeeper leader election and use of kafkastore.connection.url for ZooKeeper leader election ZooKeeper leader election were removed in Confluent Platform 7.0.0. Kafka leader election should be used instead. For details, see Migration from ZooKeeper primary election to Kafka primary election.

To migrate from ZooKeeper based to Kafka based primary election, see the migration details.

Don’t Modify These Storage Settings

Schema Registry stores all schemas in a Kafka topic defined by kafkastore.topic. Since this Kafka topic acts as the commit log for Schema Registry database and is the source of truth, writes to this store need to be durable. Schema Registry ships with very good defaults for all settings that affect the durability of writes to the Kafka based commit log. Finally, kafkastore.topic must be a compacted topic to avoid data loss. Whenever in doubt, leave these settings alone. If you must create the topic manually, this is an example of proper configuration:

# kafkastore.topic=_schemas
  bin/kafka-topics --create --bootstrap-server localhost:9092 --topic _schemas --replication-factor 3 --partitions 1 --config cleanup.policy=compact

kafkastore.topic

The durable single partition topic that acts as the durable log for the data. This topic must be compacted to avoid losing data due to retention policy.

  • Type: string
  • Default: “_schemas”
  • Importance: high

kafkastore.topic.replication.factor

The desired replication factor of the schema topic. The actual replication factor will be the smaller of this value and the number of live Kafka brokers.

  • Type: int
  • Default: 3
  • Importance: high

kafkastore.init.timeout.ms

The timeout for initialization of the Kafka store, including creation of the Kafka topic that stores schema data.

  • Type: int
  • Default: 60000
  • Importance: medium

Migration from ZooKeeper primary election to Kafka primary election

Important

ZooKeeper leader election and use of kafkastore.connection.url for ZooKeeper leader election were removed in Confluent Platform 7.0. Kafka leader election should be used instead. This section explains how to reconfigure for Kafka leader election.

To migrate from ZooKeeper based to Kafka based primary election, make the following configuration changes in all Schema Registry nodes:

  • Remove kafkastore.connection.url.
  • Remove schema.registry.zk.namespace if it is configured.
  • Configure kafkastore.bootstrap.servers.
  • Configure schema.registry.group.id if you originally had schema.registry.zk.namespace for multiple Schema Registry clusters.

If both kafkastore.connection.url and kafkastore.bootstrap.servers are configured, Kafka will be used for leader election.

Downtime for Writes

You can migrate from ZooKeeper based primary election to Kafka based primary election by following below outlined steps. These steps would lead to Schema Registry not being available for writes for a brief amount of time.

  • Make above outlined config changes on that node and also ensure leader.eligibility is set to false in all the nodes
  • Do a rolling bounce of all the nodes.
  • Configure leader.eligibility to true on the nodes that can be primary eligible and bounce them

Complete Downtime

If you want to keep things simple, you can take a temporary downtime for Schema Registry and do the migration. To do so, simply shutdown all the nodes and start them again with the new configs.

Backup and Restore

As discussed in Kafka backend, all schemas, subject/version and ID metadata, and compatibility settings are appended as messages to a special Kafka topic <kafkastore.topic> (default _schemas). This topic is a common source of truth for schema IDs, and you should back it up. In case of some unexpected event that makes the topic inaccessible, you can restore this schemas topic from the backup, enabling consumers to continue to read Kafka messages that were sent in the Avro format.

As a best practice, we recommend backing up the <kafkastore.topic>. You have three different options for doing so, as described below.

Backups using Replicator

If you already have a multi-datacenter Kafka deployment, you can back up the <kafkastore.topic> (_schemas) to another Kafka cluster using Confluent Replicator.

Backups using a sink connector

Alternatively, you can use a sink-to-storage connector, like the Kafka Connect Amazon S3 sink connector, to back up your data to a separate storage (for example, AWS S3) and continuously keep it updated in storage. Note that the <kafkastore.topic> (_schemas) must be copied over as raw data (bytes). There are a couple of ways to do this using the Connect S3 sink connector:

  • To store Kafka records and the _schemas topic in S3, use the ByteArrayConverter to back up the _schemas topic to S3 as raw data. You can then use the topics or topics.regex configuration property to list other Kafka topics to back up to S3. (See Kafka Sink Connector Configuration Reference for Confluent Platform for descriptions of topics and topics.regex.)
  • If you want to store Kafka records in JSON, AVRO, or Parquet, you can use one S3 sink connector to back up a list of Kafka topics to S3. You then create a second S3 sink connector to copy the _schemas topic to S3 using Bytes format.

Backups using command line tools

In lieu of either of the above options, you can use Kafka command line tools to periodically save the contents of the topic to a file. For the following examples, we assume that <kafkastore.topic> has its default value _schemas.

To back up the topic using command line tools, use the kafka-console-consumer to capture messages from the schemas topic to a file called schemas.log. Save this file off the Kafka cluster.

bin/kafka-console-consumer --bootstrap-server localhost:9092 --topic _schemas --from-beginning --property print.key=true --timeout-ms 1000 1> schemas.log

To restore the topic, use the kafka-console-producer to write the contents of file schemas.log to a new schemas topic. This examples uses a new schemas topic name _schemas_restore. If you use a new topic name or use the old one (_schemas), make sure to set <kafkastore.topic> accordingly.

bin/kafka-console-producer --broker-list localhost:9092 --topic _schemas_restore --property parse.key=true < schemas.log